Turquoise has been a beloved gemstone for centuries, adorning beautiful jewelry pieces across different cultures and eras. Vintage turquoise jewelry holds a special charm, with its unique characteristics and historical significance. However, identifying whether turquoise is truly vintage can be a challenging task. In this article, we’ll explore various aspects and methods to help you tell if turquoise is vintage.
Understanding the Appearance of Vintage Turquoise
Color Variations
Natural Color Differences: Vintage turquoise often displays a distinct range of colors. It can range from a soft, pale blue to a deep, rich greenish-blue. Some older pieces might have colors that have mellowed or changed slightly over time due to exposure to air, light, and other environmental factors. For example, you might notice a more muted tone compared to modern, brightly colored turquoise. In some cases, vintage turquoise from certain regions like Persian turquoise can have a unique, intense blue that was prized in earlier times and is a telltale sign of its age.
Patina and Color Fading: One of the key aspects is the patina that develops on vintage turquoise. Over the years, the surface of the stone can take on a slightly different hue or a hazy appearance. This can be due to the oxidation of certain elements within the turquoise or the absorption of substances from its surroundings. You might see areas where the color has faded a bit more on the edges or parts that were more exposed, which is a common occurrence in older pieces.
Surface Texture
Wear and Tear Marks: Vintage turquoise jewelry usually shows signs of wear. The surface of the stone might have small scratches or abrasions from being worn regularly over time. These marks are often irregular and vary in depth and length. For example, on a vintage turquoise bead necklace, you can observe how the beads have rubbed against each other or against clothing, leaving these telltale signs of use.
Polish and Finish: Older turquoise pieces might have a different type of polish compared to modern ones. In the past, the polishing techniques were not as refined in some cases, so the surface of the turquoise might have a slightly less smooth or more matte finish. You can feel the texture by gently running your finger over the stone. Some vintage pieces may even have a hand-polished look with a bit of unevenness that gives them a unique charm.
Studying the Setting and Mounting
Metal Types and Styles
Common Metals Used: In vintage turquoise jewelry, certain metals were more prevalent. Silver was a popular choice, especially in Native American and Southwestern jewelry. You can look for the type of silver used. Sterling silver is often marked with a stamp like “925” to indicate its purity. Older pieces might also use coin silver or even silver alloys with a slightly different composition. If you see a piece with a base metal that was commonly used in a particular era, it can be a clue to its vintage status.
Metalwork Styles: The style of the metalwork around the turquoise can also indicate its age. For example, in Art Deco-era jewelry from the early 20th century, the metal settings were often characterized by geometric shapes, sharp angles, and intricate filigree work. In contrast, Victorian-era settings might be more elaborate with floral motifs and detailed engravings. By recognizing these distinct metalwork styles, you can better assess if the turquoise piece is vintage.
Mounting Techniques
Prong Settings: Vintage prong settings can vary in design. Older prongs might be thicker or have a more handcrafted look. They were sometimes less precise than modern machine-made prongs. You can examine how the prongs hold the turquoise in place. In some vintage pieces, the prongs might show signs of being adjusted or repaired over time, which is a sign of its long history of wear and use.
Bezel Settings: Bezel settings in vintage jewelry also have their own characteristics. The edges of the bezel might not be as perfectly smooth as in contemporary pieces. There could be small indentations or irregularities where the bezel was shaped and soldered onto the piece. Additionally, the height and thickness of the bezel can differ based on the era it was made in, with older bezels sometimes having a more substantial look.
Looking at the Jewelry Design and Style
Cultural and Regional Influences
Native American Designs: Vintage Native American turquoise jewelry is highly sought after. Different tribes had their own distinct styles. For example, Navajo jewelry often features large, chunky turquoise stones set in bold silver settings with simple yet striking geometric patterns. Zuni jewelry, on the other hand, is known for its intricate inlay work, where small pieces of turquoise are combined with other gemstones to create detailed designs like animal motifs or abstract patterns. Recognizing these tribal styles can help you identify if a piece is vintage and from a particular Native American origin.
Southwestern Style: The Southwestern style of turquoise jewelry became popular in the United States and incorporated elements of Native American design along with a more rustic and bold aesthetic. It often includes turquoise set in silver with elements like conchos, rope borders, and large, statement-making pieces. If a piece has these characteristic Southwestern elements and shows signs of age in its design details, it could be vintage.
Era-Specific Designs
Art Nouveau: In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, during the Art Nouveau period, turquoise jewelry was designed with flowing, organic lines. The emphasis was on natural forms, and turquoise might be set in pieces that mimicked the curves of plants or the shapes of animals. The metalwork was often delicate and incorporated elements like enamel or other gemstones to enhance the overall design.
Mid-Century Modern: In the mid-20th century, jewelry designs became more streamlined and minimalist. Turquoise was used in simple settings, sometimes in geometric shapes or as part of a modernist composition. Pieces from this era might have a sleek, understated look compared to the more elaborate designs of earlier periods.
Checking for Hallmarks and Signatures
Hallmark Identification
Silver Hallmarks: As mentioned earlier, silver pieces usually have hallmarks. These can tell you the purity of the silver and sometimes the maker or the region where it was produced. For example, a piece with a specific hallmark from a well-known silversmith in a particular city during a certain era can provide strong evidence of its vintage nature. You can research these hallmarks online or consult reference books on jewelry hallmarks to decode them.
Maker’s Marks: Some jewelry makers would sign their pieces with their initials or a unique symbol. Identifying these maker’s marks can help you trace the history of the piece. If it’s a mark associated with a known jeweler from the past, it can confirm that the turquoise jewelry is vintage. However, keep in mind that not all vintage pieces will have visible marks, especially if they were made by smaller, less-known artisans.
Signatures on Native American Pieces
Tribal Signatures: In Native American turquoise jewelry, certain tribes or individual artists would leave their signatures or symbols on the piece. For example, some Zuni artists have distinct markings that they use to identify their work. Learning about these tribal and individual signatures can help you authenticate and determine the vintage status of the jewelry, as well as its origin within the Native American community.
Considering Provenance and History
Documentation and Story
Original Receipts or Papers: If a piece of turquoise jewelry comes with any original documentation like a receipt from a jeweler, an appraisal from a past date, or a certificate of authenticity, it can be a valuable resource in determining its vintage nature. These documents can provide details about when it was purchased, where it was from, and any special features or provenance associated with the piece.
Family Heirlooms and Stories: Many vintage turquoise pieces are passed down through families. The stories that accompany them can give clues about their age and origin. For example, if it’s known that a piece was bought during a specific trip to a particular region in the early 20th century or was a gift from a certain time period, it helps in establishing its vintage status.
Antique Store and Auction Records
Antique Store Provenance: If a piece was acquired from a reputable antique store, they might have records or information about its history. They could have sourced it from a particular collection or estate sale, and this background knowledge can add to the evidence of its vintage nature.
Auction Catalogs: Looking at past auction catalogs where similar turquoise jewelry was sold can give you an idea of how old a piece might be. You can compare the design, materials, and any markings on your piece with those in the catalogs to see if it matches the characteristics of known vintage items.
Using Scientific Testing (When Appropriate)
Gemological Testing
Hardness and Density Tests: While not commonly done by the average collector, gemological laboratories can perform tests to determine the hardness and density of the turquoise. Vintage turquoise might have slightly different physical properties compared to modern, treated specimens. For example, natural, untreated vintage turquoise might have a hardness within a specific range on the Mohs scale that can be compared to known standards for different types of turquoise from various eras.
Chemical Composition Analysis: Advanced chemical analysis
can reveal the elements present in the turquoise. This can help identify if it’s from a particular region or if it has been treated. Some vintage turquoise might have a chemical makeup that is characteristic of the mines where it was originally sourced in the past, and this can be a way to confirm its authenticity and age.
Non-Destructive Testing Methods
UV Light Examination: Under ultraviolet light, vintage turquoise can react differently compared to modern, synthetic, or treated versions. Some natural vintage turquoise might show a specific fluorescence pattern that can be used as an indicator of its authenticity and age. However, this method is not always conclusive on its own and needs to be combined with other identification techniques.
Infrared Spectroscopy: This is a more technical method that can be used by professionals to analyze the molecular structure of the turquoise. It can help detect if there are any additives or treatments applied to the stone, which can be important in distinguishing between vintage, untreated turquoise and modern, processed stones.
Conclusion
Telling if turquoise is vintage requires a combination of careful observation, knowledge of jewelry history, and sometimes scientific testing. By looking at its appearance, the setting, the design, checking for hallmarks and considering its provenance, you can build a more accurate picture of whether a piece of turquoise jewelry is truly vintage. It’s a fascinating process that allows you to uncover the stories and history behind these beautiful gemstone adornments and appreciate their unique value in the world of jewelry. Remember, each aspect provides a piece of the puzzle, and when put together, they can help you make a more informed determination about the vintage nature of turquoise jewelry.
Related Topics:
